Home Top Stories One Show Raises Alarm Bells About AI In Podcasting
Top Stories

One Show Raises Alarm Bells About AI In Podcasting

Share
One Show Raises Alarm Bells About AI In Podcasting
Share

By now, there’s possibly no adult that has not heard about the potential and the danger of Artificial Intelligence (AI). It seems like every day brings another frightening tale of an AI agent out of control of its human overlords and attacking another computer program or government website.

In podcasting, AI tools can hallucinate facts, invent fake citations, or generate bland, confrontational scripts that lack genuine conversational depth. Synthetic voices often struggle with natural pacing, emotional inflection, chuckles, or thoughtful pauses, resulting in flat and robotic listening experiences. While AI can clean up background noise, it cannot fix root human errors like poor interview structure or distorted room acoustics. Automatically generating content, show notes, or synthetic host audio exposes creators to copyright infringement, defamation claims, and guest privacy violations.

Make no mistake. AI-generated podcasts are flooding the market, with studios producing hundreds of thousands of episodes that sound increasingly indistinguishable from human hosts.

The technology offers cost savings and opportunities for creators, but many in the industry worry AI hosts undermine listener trust and devalue premium content.

Some popular podcasters, including Steven Bartlett, are cloning their voices for AI content, while others are pushing back against the technology’s rapid expansion.

In a December 2025 article, the Los Angeles Times reported: “Popular podcast host Steven Bartlett has used an AI clone to launch a new kind of content aimed at the 13 million followers of his podcast “Diary of a CEO.” On YouTube, his clone narrates “100 CEOs With Steven Bartlett,” which adds AI-generated animation to Bartlett’s cloned voice to tell the life stories of entrepreneurs such as Steve Jobs and Richard Branson.

Platforms such as YouTube and Spotify have introduced features for creators to clone their voice and translate their content into multiple languages to increase reach and revenue. A new generation of voice cloning companies, many with operations in California, offers better emotion, tone, pacing and overall voice quality.

ForbesHow AI Is Changing Work And The Human Experience

Hume AI, which is based in New York but has a big research team in California, raised $50 million last year and has tens of thousands of creators using its software to generate audiobooks, podcasts, films, voice-overs for videos and dialogue generation in video games.

Los Angeles podcasting studio Inception Point AI has produced its 200,000 podcast episodes, in some weeks accounting for 1% of all podcasts published that week on the internet, according to CEO Jeanine Wright.

The podcasts are so cheap to make that they can focus on tiny topics, like local weather, small sports teams, gardening and other niche subjects.

Instead of a studio searching for a specific “hit” podcast idea, it takes just $1 to produce an episode so that they can be profitable with just 25 people listening.

“That means most of the stuff that we make, we have really an unlimited amount of experimentation and creative freedom for what we want to do,” Wright said.

One of its popular synthetic hosts is Vivian Steele, an AI celebrity gossip columnist with a sassy voice and a sharp tongue. “I am indeed AI-powered — which means I’ve got receipts older than your grandmother’s jewelry box, and a memory sharper than a stiletto heel on marble. No forgetting, no forgiving, and definitely no filter,” the AI discloses itself at the start of the podcast.

“We’ve kind of molded her more towards what the audience wants,” said Katie Brown, chief content officer at Inception Point, who helps design the personalities of the AI podcasters.

James Cridland noted In Podnews: “The same technology that makes your production workflow smoother, if used carelessly, can expose you to copyright claims, privacy violations, or even lawsuits from guests, collaborators, sponsors, and members of the public.”

Cridland adds: “What this means is that when you use an AI system to generate art, music, or text, you can’t always know where its ‘inspiration’ came from. If the tool you’re using spits out something too similar to an existing copyrighted work, you could find wind up publishing an infringing derivative work. And in the crosshairs of a costly, time-consuming and embarrassing lawsuit.”

Over one recent nine-day stretch, nearly 40% of new podcasts were likely AI-generated, according to Podcast Index, as reported by Bloomberg. One company alone, Inception Point AI, now claims to have more than 10,000 active shows, with hundreds more appearing almost overnight.

This is publishing at industrial scale. The real question is not whether AI can make podcasts. It clearly can. The question is whether people will consume them.

Alberto Betella of RSS.com was on The Podnews Weekly Review and offered useful ways to think about AI and podcasts: “Not all AI podcasts are the same and treating them as one category muddies the issue. There are AI-assisted podcasts where humans use tools to improve production. No problem. There are AI-curated utility podcasts delivering structured information. Seems fine.”

Mr. Betella continues: “Then there is spam designed to manipulate systems. This is the podcast version of fake handbags with familiar-looking names, cover art and feeds created to confuse, capture a click, or game search returns. That is simply deceptive and horrible.”

Then there is what many are calling podslop: fully automated shows produced at scale with little human judgment and even less accountability.

Betella’s useful point is that AI slop is not binary. It’s a spectrum. A weak AI podcast about golf may be annoying. A weak AI podcast offering health advice or financial guidance can become something else entirely. The point is AI itself is not the concern, it’s the potential impact.

Podcasting works because it feels human.

It is a voice you come back to, a perspective you recognize, and a sense that someone has done the work and is speaking with intention. This is where many AI podcasts break down. It can mimic tone, but rarely carries conviction, personality, or a natural human rhythm – a giggle, or an “oh my.” The delivery often feels flat and emotionally empty.

A more practical place to begin is disclosure. Identifying when a portion of a podcast is AI-generated creates transparency for listeners, flexibility for advertisers, and a basic framework for platforms.

Hitting A High Note For Human Voices

A Season Dedicated To The AI threat

Season 4 of High Notes, launched on Thursday October 8th with episodes that will run for seven weeks. The season will see host Melissa Thom talking to leading figures on both sides of the AI debate: those whose voices have been affected by AI, and those using it for good.

In this fourth season of the podcast, Melissa Thom asks: “What happens to the human voice as AI gets good enough to replicate it?”

Melissa says: “It’s a conversation that reaches further than most people think, affecting not just performers, but anyone who’s ever recorded a voice note, sat in on a Zoom call, or had their voice used by the business they work for. If you speak for a living, work with people who do, or just want to understand what’s happening to your own voice in an AI-shaped world, this season’s for you.”

The full lineup of episodes and release dates are as follows:

Thursday 8th October
Episode 01: AI or human voice? Why brands choose both, with Mark Graeme from OCX (Omnicom Production) and Mark Eaves from Gravity Road

This episode explores when and why a creative studio chooses AI over a human voice, and when it doesn’t, from two vantage points in the advertising industry.

Mark Graeme is Head of Studio at OCX UK (Omnicom Production, part of Omnicom Group, the world’s leading marketing and sales company). Mark and his team produce work for creative agencies such as Adam & Eve/TBWA, AMVBBDO, and McCann, plus work directly with a mix of local and global brands. He has also hosted the Shiny Awards, supporting emerging directing talent.

Mark Eaves is Founder of Gravity Road, part of The Brand Tech Group, working across brands including Unilever, Booking.com and TikTok. He led Gravity Road’s build of ‘Ode,’ an AI poetry companion made in partnership with Microsoft AI and Poetry Pharmacy founder William Sieghart. ‘Ode’ is trained on Sieghart’s own voice to listen and prescribe a poem. A real actor reads every poem aloud — Stephen Fry, Harriet Walter, Dominic West and Indira Varma among them — rather than a synthetic voice.

Between them, Melissa gets the industry-wide picture and one deeply considered case study, both circling the same question creative directors are still grappling with: AI or human voice?

Thursday 15th October

Episode 02: Cloned Without Consent, with Voice Actor Faye Dicker and Equity’s Shannon Sailing

Voice actor Faye Dicker discovered her voice had been cloned and sold via a US platform without her consent. It was downloaded more than 900 times before it was taken down. She’s joined by Shannon Sailing, Industrial Official for Audio and Games, from Equity, who dealt with Faye’s case and is now handling a wave of similar claims.

Thursday 22nd October

Episode 03: UK AI Law: Unfit for Purpose? With Dr. Mathilde Pavis

In this episode, Melissa talks to Dr Mathilde Pavis, an expert in intellectual property law, ethics and new technologies, who helped build Equity’s AI toolkit and has worked directly with AI platforms including ElevenLabs. Melissa asks why the UK currently has no personality right for voice, how that compares to other countries, and whether the law is keeping up. The real value here is practical: exactly what to check, ask and do to protect your own voice, as things stand today. The landscape is changing fast, so staying informed matters more than ever.

Thursday 29th October

Ep 04: Across all sectors: Games, Dubbing, Ads and Animation with Actor and Voiceover Artist David Menkin

David Menkin is a London-based actor and voiceover artist with an impressive portfolio across commercials, dubbing, animation and gaming, including major AAA titles, Lego Star Wars, Final Fantasy XVI and Pragmata. In this episode, Melissa talks to him about how working across these four sectors creates very different relationships with AI risk. They also discuss David’s advocacy work on how studios treat performers, and whether any one sector is leading the way in AI and human voice working together.

Thursday 5th November

Episode 05: The Audiobook Pipeline with Award-Winning Director, Dan Jones
Storytelling’s as old as language, but the recorded audiobook industry is barely three generations old, and already facing real disruption. AI-narrated titles now make up around 23% of new releases in the US, and Audible alone has released over 40,000. Yet the Audio Publishers Association’s own data shows willingness to actually try AI narration has been falling, not rising. Dan Jones spent 22 years at Hachette, one of the world’s biggest publishers, including 7 as Head of Audio Services, and is now an Audio Specialist and Senior Manager at Glassboxx, and a visiting coach at BRAVA. We ask Dan how decisions get made at scale, what he wishes more performers understood about the other side of the process, and where he thinks the human voice in audiobooks is headed.

Thursday 12th November
Episode 06: Owning and protecting your voice with BAFTA award-winning actress, Cissy Jones
Melissa talks to BAFTA award-winning actress Cissy Jones, known for voicing Delilah in Firewatch, alongside performances in The Walking Dead, Baldur’s Gate 3, Fallout 4, Starfield, Life is Strange, Halo 5 and The Owl House. Cissy is co-founder and CEO of US-based company Ethovox, the only voice AI company owned and run by voice actors.

Ethovox has an agreement with SAG-AFTRA, made during the video game Interactive Media Agreement negotiations, to build a foundational voice model on a union contract. How an individual performer’s own voice replica is actually used, SAG or non-SAG, remains a separate decision made by that performer and their agent. Melissa asks Cissy what performers should check before licensing their voice, and whether her model is the exception to the rule or a preview of where the rest of the industry is heading.

Thursday 18th November

Ep 07: Negotiating AI: Inside a Talent Agency with Bonnie Nordling
AI is now a significant factor in negotiating VO contracts, so in this episode Melissa sits down with Bonnie Nordling and asks what negotiation looks like in a talent agency for 2026. Bonnie is the MD of Nordlings, representing around 200 voice actors across commercials, animation, and gaming. Bonnie talks through her agency’s approach to negotiating AI clauses, where AI and human voice are working well together across her roster, and where more work remains. She also gives her take on the agent’s role in the age of AI, and what she thinks the future holds.

Voiceover Artists Versus AI

Melissa Thom observes: “We’re at a moment when AI can replicate, reshape and deploy a voice in ways most of us are only beginning to understand. This season is about making sense of that change and giving everyone who uses their voice — professionally or personally — the conversation, context and tools they need to navigate what comes next.”

Melissa continues: “AI has reshaped the voiceover landscape at extraordinary speed and it’s here to stay. It has driven an irreversible shift: fast, cost-effective, and adequate for functional jobs, but limited when it comes to depth, nuance, and genuine human connection. The risks are clear: fewer entry-level opportunities, ethical concerns, and the rise of synthetic competition. Yet there is also opportunity in defining the line between what AI can produce and what only a trained actor can deliver: authenticity, creativity, and emotional resonance. The future will be hybrid, with AI handling routine work, and human voices bringing the storytelling that truly connects.”

For me, the replacement of human voices by artificial intelligence raises major concerns about ethics, economic displacement, deception risks, and the loss of emotional authenticity. Highly realistic AI voices can be weaponized by bad actors to commit phone fraud, such as pretending to be a distressed relative or an authority figure. Research shows that people hearing synthetic voices matching underrepresented regional dialects are even more vulnerable to falling for audio scams.

The human cost of AI can not be fully calculated. Entry-level and lower-paying voice-over jobs—such as corporate training, automated phone menus (IVR), and basic narration—are increasingly automated to cut costs, threatening livelihoods in the industry. Is AI a clone of globalism from the 90s, where many may benefit but millions will suffer?

Finally, there’s The Trust Gap. Audiences report feeling deceived or less favorable toward public-facing media, radio stations, and creative projects that hide the use of synthetic audio instead of using genuine human performers.

Melissa Thom of BRAVA and High Notes drives home her point about the magic of human voiceovers: “There are well-known masters of the craft. Robin Williams’s Genie in Aladdin is perhaps the most famous example of a voice performance reshaping the film and the impact of the character on an audience. His energy and improvisation changed how studios thought about casting voices for decades afterwards. Sometimes, when the voice is right it can often become bigger than the film itself; think of Mike Myers and Eddie Murphy in Shrek, Scarlett Johanssen in HER, where the voice is the entire character, with no physical body to lean on; James Earl Jones as Darth Vader in Star Wars or my own personal favourite, Andy Serkis as Gollum in Lord of the Rings. These performances go way beyond the script and embed themselves in popular culture. ”

Melissa emphasizes the value of human voiceovers: “If we go beyond animation and look at the wider creative industries we can see how voice brings these performances to life. In games, the voice often carries players through dozens of hours of story, and it’s the performance that makes them care whether a character lives or dies. In TV and film, a narrator sets the emotional temperature of an entire documentary. Just think of Morgan Freeman in March of the Penguins. In advertising, a voice can become a brand’s identity in a few seconds.”



Source link

Share

Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *