NASHVILLE, TN – NOVEMBER 1: Nashville SC forward Hany Mukhtar (10) lifts the Supporters’ Shield on stage following a match between Nashville SC and Red Bull New York, November 1, 2026, at GEODIS Park in Nashville, Tennessee. (Photo by Matthew Maxey/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)
Icon Sportswire via Getty Images
The MLS Cup Playoffs kicked off on Thursday night with a pair of wildcard matches that pit the eighth- and ninth-place teams in each conference against each other.
In the Western Conference, the Seattle Sounders welcomed Real Salt Lake.
In the Eastern Conference, Orlando City SC hosted FC Cincinnati.
Nashville SC will try to accomplish a feat that has become difficult to duplicate in recent years – win the Supporters’ Shield and MLS Cup.
The Supporters’ Shield is awarded to the team that accrues the most points in a season. That follows suit with the rest of the world.
However, North America is the home of the playoffs. The actual champion isn’t determined until one team is left standing.
NASHVILLE, TENNESSEE – SEPTEMBER 26: B.J. Callaghan of Nashville SC claps from the sideline against the Toronto FC in the second half at GEODIS Park on September 26, 2026 in Nashville, Tennessee. (Photo by Carly Mackler/Getty Images)
Getty Images
Best MLS regular season ever
The team from Music City had the greatest regular season in the 31-year-old league’s history.
Nashville (23-3-8, 77 points) finished atop the Eastern Conference as runaway leaders, 17 points ahead of Lionel Messi and second-place Inter Miami CF (16-6-12, 6). In baseball terms, that is six games or victories ahead of Miami. That is a huge margin for a 34-game schedule. Those 77 points were an MLS record, as were the 23 wins.
Just as impressive was the squad’s home record of 15-0-2 at GEODIS Park, the best in MLS history.
NASHVILLE, TENNESSEE – AUGUST 29: Hany Mukhtar #10 of Nashville SC celebrates scoring his team’s second goal during the MLS match between Nashville SC and FC Cincinnati at GEODIS Park on August 29, 2026 in Nashville, Tennessee. (Photo by Chris Carter/MLS via Getty Images)
MLS via Getty Images
The team has quality and quantity
So much has gone so well for Nashville SC.
* On Monday, Nov. 16, Maxwell Woledzi was named MLS Defender of the Year. Teammates Jeisson Palacios and Andy Najar were the only two finalists.
* On Wednesday, Nov. 18, Brian Schwake was selected as MLS Goalkeeper of the Year.
* The fabulous Hany Mukhtar is one of five finalists for league MVP honors.
* It certainly wouldn’t be a surprise if B.J. Callaghan is named Coach of the Year.
* And while he isn’t up for any individual awards, forward Sam Surridge finished third in league scoring with 21 goals. Surridge could be voted to the MLS Best XI.
So, there is plenty of quality in the Starting XI.
NASHVILLE, TENNESSEE – NOVEMBER 01: Maxwell Woledzi #3 of Nashville SC celebrates after winning the MLS match between Nashville SC and Red Bull New York at GEODIS Park on November 01, 2026 in Nashville, Tennessee. (Photo by Nashville SC/MLS via Getty Images)
MLS via Getty Images
First a marathon, then a sprint
But as we have learned through the years, you can throw the regular season out the window for many of the top teams.
Entering this year’s postseason, only 11 Supporters’ Shield champions have won MLS Cup championships over the three decades. That’s a 36.6 percent success rate.
Not very successful.
Still, after all these years, pundits, media, and fans have continued to pick the Supporters’ Shield winners to take it all.
Their regular season record can be quite enticing. After all, everyone loves a winner, especially one that has endured 34 matches.
However, we need to remember that the regular season and playoffs are two different entities.
The former is a marathon, where teams can survive poor play over a few games and injuries over time. Teams can add newcomers to their roster who can boost production.
The playoffs are a sprint. It is a much shorter season. Even if a wildcard team reached the MLS Cup on Dec. 18, it will play “only” seven contests. That is a sprint compared to 34 games.
HARRISON, NJ – NOVEMBER 29: Members of the Columbus Crew celebrate their Eastern Conference win over the New York Red Bulls after their match at Red Bull Arena on November 29, 2015 in Harrison, New Jersey. (Photo by Jeff Zelevansky/Getty Images)
Getty Images
The ghosts of the 2015 MLS Cup Playoffs
On Wednesday, this writer got an opportunity to ask a pair of former Major League Soccer standouts – Sacha Kljestan and Dax McCarty – who are commentators and analysts for Major League Soccer games on Apple TV.
Neither player won an MLS Cup, but they were members of a very good New York Red Bulls team (now called Red Bull New York) that captured the 2015 Supporters’ Shield.
The team finished at 18-10-6 with 60 points. The Red Bulls defeated D.C. United in the conference semifinals, 2-0, before losing to the Columbus Crew in the Eastern final, 2-1.
I asked both men what sort of advice they would give Nashville as the top seed, with everything to lose.
29 NOV 2015: New York Red Bulls midfielder Sacha Kljestan (16) during the second half of the MLS Eastern Conference Championship game being played at Red Bull Arena in Harrison,NJ. (Photo by Rich Graessle/Icon Sportswire) (Photo by Rich Graessle/Icon Sportswire/Corbis/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)
Corbis/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images
Kjjestan: Be ready from the first whistle
“First of all, be ready from the first whistle because we got scored on after nine seconds in the Eastern Conference final against Columbus Crew,” Kljestan said. “Then you get behind the eight ball, and then you’re digging and clawing to try to get yourself back into the game, which is not really a spot that Nashville has been in much this year. They’ve started games so well at home.
“Even when they’ve played these trap games towards the end of the season against whoever it was at the bottom of the table, they come out flying, and they’re up in your face. So, I would say stick to who they have been and be ready from the first whistle because in a playoff series or a playoff game, if you go down early, the game changes. The other team can just sit back and defend and try to make it as hard as possible.
“Then you start to feel that stress and that anxiety. So, I would say, Nashville, I’d urge them to have a good start, continue to do what they do. And then there’s this pressure that you feel because you’re expected [to win]. We knew that Nashville was very good throughout the course of the season, but now the expectation is that you have to back it up. I’m interested to see during these early games how they deal with that pressure and that anxiety because things tighten up a little bit. If you make a mistake, you don’t want to cower a little bit. You need to grow into the game. I’m almost watching the body language of the entire team throughout the first series of these playoffs for Nashville.”
November 01 2015: New York Red Bulls defender Matt Miazga (20) watches as midfielder Dax McCarty (11) celebrates after scoring the winning goal during the MLS Eastern Conference semi-final first leg game at RFK Stadium against DC United, in Washington DC. Red Bulls won 1-0. (Photo by Tony Quinn/Icon Sportswire) (Photo by Tony Quinn/Icon Sportswire/Corbis/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)
Corbis/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images
McCarty says Nashville has to manage its emotions
McCarty said he was impressed with Nashville’s versatility, noting their ability to adapt to various styles through the 2026 campaign.
“I think managing emotions is probably going to be the key for Nashville SC because they can play in any type of game,” he said. “We’ve seen that from them. We’ve seen them be able to be effective in all kinds of different games. If they need to sit and see how to win and defend, they can do that. If they need to press, if they need to send numbers forward, if they need to be aggressive, counter-pressing, high line, you name it. That’s why I think they’re the best team top to bottom in Major League Soccer: because they are the most balanced team in terms of different identities and styles of play.
“B.J. Callaghan, he always is aggressive to go after the game. But Sacha’s right. When the pressure is ramped up, when the emotions are ramped up, can you manage the game in an effective way? I think that’s the question for every single team, because right now, Nashville SC is the dominant team in Major League Soccer. They have the target on their back. They didn’t last year; they didn’t the year before that.”
Interestingly, McCarty downplayed home-field advantage in the postseason.
“We know from experience with our Red Bull teams that it doesn’t really matter what you do in the regular season, that you are going to get the best shot of every team that comes up against you,” he said. “And just the fact that you have home-field advantage or you might play the last game at home, that doesn’t really mean all that much if you don’t take advantage of it. I would say the biggest thing for Nashville is to stay composed. It felt like our Red Bull teams at times, specifically in 2015 and even 2016, where I still felt like we were the best team in the league. We gave up goals that were fantastic finishes.”
But the Red Bulls did not play well from behind in those MLS Cup Playoffs.
“I don’t think we managed going behind really well,” he said. “We didn’t stay composed. We made mistakes. We missed big chances in the final third. And honestly, [we] were playing collectively as a group at such a high level for the entire year, and it felt like not enough of us had good games and not enough of us played up to our potential in the playoffs for whatever reason. That ends up hurting you in the end.
“Can Nashville stay composed? Can they make sure they understand that they will have a target on their back and that the pressure is going to be ramped up a notch? And then if fluky, weird things happen, because they do in the playoffs. Bad calls from the referee, red cards, fluky goals either conceded or given up. Can you manage those emotions? Can you methodically get back into the game? And then can you also go and manage the pressure and the emotion of what it means to be the best team in the league? That’s going to be where they need to handle the most pressure.”
LOS ANGELES, CA – NOVEMBER 06: Ilie Sánchez #6 of Los Angeles FC holds the Philip F. Anschutz Trophy on his head while parading around the stadium on top of open double decker bus during the MLS Cup victory parade and celebration next to Banc of California Stadium on November 6, 2022 in Los Angeles, California. (Photo by Kevork Djansezian/Getty Images)
Getty Images
Winning the league and the playoffs have been rare lately
How difficult has it been for Supporters’ Shield champions to take a final victory lap with the Philip F. Anschutz Trophy?
Only one team – Los Angeles FC – has demonstrated the resolve to win the regular season and playoff titles in 2022. That is four years ago. In fact, LAFC is the only team to win both trophies in the last nine seasons.
That is an eye-opening statistic.
In case you were wondering, winning the regular season and playoffs was much more common in the league’s earlier years.
Five Supporters’ Shield champions also danced around with the playoff trophy in the league’s opening eight seasons.
The only team to have won both ends of the campaign twice is D.C. United, which did so in 1997 and 1999.
Many questions remain as the playoffs begin.
* Can Messi lead an Inter Miami CF squad that has shown great defensive vulnerability, which could become a liability when push comes to shove, especially in the later rounds?
* Can last year’s runners-up, the Vancouver Whitecaps, reach MLS Cup again? The Caps might be playing a bit under the radar because of Nashville SC’s success and Inter Miami’s star power.
* And can Nashville SC prove to be marathon men and sprinters in the same calendar year?
If the team can, it will prove to be one of the great teams in MLS history.
Nashville SC needs to take care of business over the next month and at the MLS Cup on Dec. 18 to do so.
Michael Lewis, the editor of FrontRowSoccer.com, and the author of 10 books about the beautiful game, can be reached at @Soccerwriter on X and Bluesky.

Leave a comment